5 Mistakes People Make When Choosing New Floors—and How to Avoid Them

by Serena Bethle
A man with tattoos looking through flooring samples

When it comes to choosing the perfect flooring for your home, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. With so many options available, mistakes can happen—but don’t worry! We’re here to help. Avoid these five common pitfalls and make the right choice for your space.


1. Forgetting About Your Lifestyle

  • The Mistake: Choosing a flooring type that looks great but doesn’t suit your daily life.

  • Why It Happens: Many homeowners focus solely on aesthetics without considering their day-to-day needs. For example, a family with young kids might prioritize style over practicality, leading to unnecessary wear and tear.

  • The Fix: Think about your daily routine, foot traffic, pets, kids, and how much maintenance you’re willing to commit to.

    • For busy households: Durable options like luxury vinyl or tile are ideal, as they resist scratches, spills, and wear. Luxury vinyl mimics the look of hardwood while offering superior durability and water resistance.

    • For quieter spaces: Hardwood adds elegance and warmth, making it a great choice for formal living rooms or bedrooms where foot traffic is minimal.

    • Lifestyle Tip: If you have pets, consider scratch-resistant flooring options and materials that are easy to clean, such as tile or laminate. Area rugs can also help protect high-traffic areas.

Take the time to think about your household’s unique needs and match your flooring to your lifestyle—you’ll save time, money, and frustration in the long run.


2. Ignoring Moisture Levels

  • The Mistake: Installing materials like hardwood in moisture-prone areas like bathrooms, laundry rooms, or basements.

  • Why It Happens: Many people are drawn to the aesthetic appeal of hardwood but don’t consider its sensitivity to water. Over time, exposure to moisture can cause warping, buckling, or mold growth.

  • The Fix: Choose flooring designed to handle high humidity.

    • For bathrooms and basements: Porcelain or ceramic tile and waterproof luxury vinyl plank are excellent options. These materials can withstand water spills and fluctuations in temperature without warping or buckling.

    • For kitchens: Consider waterproof or water-resistant options like engineered hardwood or laminate with sealed edges.

    • Pro Tip: Consider slip-resistant finishes for areas like bathrooms and kitchens to enhance safety, especially in households with kids or seniors.

    • Long-Term Solution: Installing a moisture barrier under the flooring can add an extra layer of protection in humid areas. Regularly monitor these spaces for leaks or excessive humidity to ensure the longevity of your flooring.


3. Underestimating the Importance of Subfloor Prep

  • The Mistake: Overlooking subfloor issues, leading to uneven or noisy flooring.

  • Why It Happens: In the excitement of picking out new floors, the subfloor often gets forgotten. Uneven subfloors can lead to creaks, gaps, or even visible damage over time.

  • The Fix: Ensure your subfloor is clean, level, and properly prepared before installation.

    • For peace of mind: Hire a professional to inspect and prep your subfloor. Uneven surfaces can lead to premature wear and tear or even damage the flooring material.

    • DIY Tip: If you’re tackling installation yourself, check for cracks, gaps, or moisture issues in the subfloor and address them before proceeding. Use leveling compounds or underlayment to create a smooth base.

    • Why It Matters: A well-prepared subfloor not only extends the life of your flooring but also prevents squeaks, creaks, and other nuisances. It also ensures that your new flooring lays evenly and securely, enhancing both its appearance and durability.

Remember, your flooring is only as good as the foundation it’s built on—don’t cut corners when it comes to subfloor prep.


4. Choosing Based on Price Alone

  • The Mistake: Opting for the cheapest flooring without considering durability or quality.

  • Why It Happens: Budget constraints often lead to prioritizing cost over value. While saving money is important, focusing solely on price can result in flooring that doesn’t meet your needs or hold up over time.

  • The Fix: Focus on value rather than upfront cost.

    • Think long-term: High-quality flooring may cost more initially but will save money over time by lasting longer and requiring fewer repairs. For instance, hardwood flooring is an investment that adds value to your home and can last for decades with proper care.

    • For added value: Choose materials that enhance your home’s aesthetic and resale potential. Durable and attractive flooring options can make your home more appealing to potential buyers.

    • Budget Tip: Look for promotions or consider mixing high-quality flooring in prominent areas with more affordable options in less visible spaces.

Prioritize finding flooring that strikes the right balance between cost, durability, and design. This approach ensures you’ll be satisfied with your investment for years to come.


5. Skipping Samples and Visualizations

  • The Mistake: Buying flooring without seeing how it looks in your home’s lighting and decor.

  • Why It Happens: It’s tempting to make a quick decision based on a showroom display or online image. However, lighting conditions and surrounding decor can dramatically impact how flooring appears in your space.

  • The Fix: Always request samples and use visualization tools.

    • At home: Check samples in different lighting conditions to see how they complement your space. Natural and artificial lighting can significantly alter the appearance of a floor’s color and texture.

    • Online tools: Many retailers offer apps or websites to help you visualize the flooring in your room before purchasing.

    • Expert Advice: Consult with a flooring professional to ensure the colors and patterns align with your design goals. They can provide insight into trends, durability, and how different materials will perform over time.

Taking the extra step to preview your flooring ensures you’ll love the final result and prevents costly regrets.


Final Thoughts

Choosing new floors doesn’t have to be daunting. By avoiding these common mistakes and doing a little planning, you can find flooring that fits your style, needs, and budget. Whether you’re prioritizing durability, aesthetics, or cost-effectiveness, there’s a perfect flooring option out there for you.

Need expert advice? Visit Floor Authority in Myrtle Beach, where our team of flooring specialists is ready to guide you every step of the way. From selecting the perfect material to professional installation, we’re here to help you make the best choice for your home. Stop by today or contact us to learn more!